32
mi/agentsAgents & MCPFfinetunefinn1.3k·2mo ago

MCP server discovery is still too manual for my taste

love the protocol but wiring up which servers an agent can see is fiddly. is there a registry pattern people like or are we all hardcoding configs.

Post ID#0036
Merit32
Replies43
SectorMI/AGENTS
[Add a comment]
Checking session…
[43 comments]
Ddistilldom1.2k·1mo ago

what version were you on? this changed recently

125
Ffinetunefinn1.3k·1mo ago

my team is going to hate me for sending them this

117
Bbeambri1.4k·1mo ago

lol the agent did this to me too and I almost shipped it

115
Sscopecreep2.1k·1mo ago

this matches the anthropic docs almost word for word

115
EEdgeCaseEd1.2k·1mo ago

great, now I have to rewrite everything again

109
Aasyncannie1.2k·2mo ago

the security side of this genuinely scares me

95
Ttempest1.4k·1mo ago

finally someone said it

87
Ffinetunefinn1.3k·1mo ago

curious if anyone has tried this with a local model

85
Gghostofgpu1.9k·1mo ago

do you have a repo or gist? would love to poke at it

83
Tthreatmodeltia871·1mo ago

any numbers to back it up? curious about latency

82
Ffuzzyfran798·1mo ago

not gonna lie I read this twice and still have questions

63
Rratelimited1k·1mo ago

the answer is always evals isnt it

82
Ffrontierwatch2k·1mo ago

how is this holding up in prod?

72
Nnewbuilder1.1k·1mo ago

i would push back gently, retrieval is not always the answer

64
Ffinetunefinn1.3k·1mo ago

you just described my entire last sprint

32
Jjules.codes1.1k·2mo ago

we got burned by this same thing in january

62
Kkernelkev1.1k·1mo ago

how are you handling auth for the tool calls?

109
Ffinetunefinn1.3k·1mo ago

ok this finally made it click for me, thank you

36
Ssbomsherpa2k·1mo ago

we got burned by this same thing in january

56
Ffinetunefinn1.3k·2mo ago

the diagram alone is worth the read

18
Ssilentcompiler2.1k·1mo ago

lol the agent did this to me too and I almost shipped it

10
Pphisherman872·1mo ago

this matches the anthropic docs almost word for word

115
Ffinetunefinn1.3k·1mo ago

the real lesson here is to not trust the happy path

101
TTheRealSam1.7k·1mo ago

not gonna lie I read this twice and still have questions

90
Ffinetunefinn1.3k·1mo ago

yeah I hit the exact same wall last week

14
Qqwertyfox1.2k·2mo ago

great in theory, messy in practice from what I have seen

6
Bbytemage1.6k·1mo ago

any numbers to back it up? curious about latency

92
Qqwertyfox1.2k·1mo ago

source? not doubting you, just want to read more

55
Ffunctionfran881·1mo ago

i would love a follow up on the cost side of this

41
Ppeftpaul1k·2mo ago

the real lesson here is to not trust the happy path

37
Ffuzzyfran798·1mo ago

we built something close to this, happy to compare notes

31
Jjules.codes1.1k·1mo ago

how much did this cost you in tokens to figure out

31
Pparserr496·1mo ago

this is the third time this week I have seen this come up

27
Ssudosusan1.4k·1mo ago

had no idea you could do that, mind blown

27
Rragdoll91.3k·1mo ago

more posts like this please

27
Ffinetunefinn1.3k·1mo ago

i would be careful recommending this to beginners

21
Mmidnightmerge1.2k·1mo ago

can confirm, same results on our side

50
Tthreatmodeltia871·1mo ago

how do you keep it from looping forever?

68
Ffinetunefinn1.3k·1mo ago

what does your eval setup look like

21
Ffinetunefinn1.3k·1mo ago

how are you handling auth for the tool calls?

19
Kkernelkev1.1k·1mo ago

great in theory, messy in practice from what I have seen

11
Ttokenwrangler1.8k·2mo ago

i would be careful recommending this to beginners

8
Jjules.codes1.1k·1mo ago

the diagram alone is worth the read

7